Renley Waffle Knit Button Up Top - FINAL SALE

I was really excited about these shirts as I was going to wear them postpartum for nursing. I ordered 4 different colors all the same size and got 4 shirts all different sizes. I checked the tags and they are all smalls. As you can tell from the pictures the buttons are even in different places. Overall, I kept the white and the pink as they were the closest size to what I ordered and fit. The charcoal grey one fit like an XS or XXS, the sleeves were tights and short and the shirt was shorter than the rest. The mint colored one fit like a medium or large and the buttons came down further on the shirt than the others. The pink and white one fit great and I love the softness of them. Overall I like the shirt, just wish the sizing was consistent so I could have kept them all.

I was going to return it at first try on, but I knew I had to try it on with my Quinn like I saw in the live on Amy! I was so thrilled at how cute it draped and elegant it looked! I was nervous since one of the reviews said they had to return from the tight arms since I was going to get size m but it wasn’t available so I got small. Small was perfect! Still room in the arms I have a build similar to Amy who wears m. I’m 5’4 and 140-145lbs. This cardigan is super buttery soft I just couldn’t give it up! Probably will save for alone putting sand church since I don’t want my toddlers to stain the white lol. Try it!!

Side note- I was only going to return since I didn’t like that I could see my shirt under but it doesn’t matter to me it’s worth the beautiful cardigan in such a fresh white! Please never discontinue for when my white is no longer white! And ladies go try the 31 inch navy Quinn it is the best skirt I’ve ever had! Not tight like a pencil skirt at all!